Fresh, brackish and marine fishkeeping with Graham Reed, The Tank Whisperer. 30+ years of wet sleeves.

How Many Fish Can I Keep? The Stocking Guide

The short answer: there’s no single formula, but as a rough start allow about 1 cm of adult fish per 2 litres of water for small, slim community fish, and much more room for big, chunky or messy fish. Stock slowly, a few fish every two weeks, and let your test kit, not the number of fish, tell you when to stop.

Why the “inch per gallon” rule lets you down

You’ll hear “one inch of fish per gallon” in every shop. It’s a starting point, nothing more. It goes wrong because:

  • Fish aren’t flat. A 10 cm goldfish weighs and poops many times more than ten 1 cm fry. Body bulk, not length, drives waste.
  • It uses adult size. That 4 cm pleco in the shop can reach 40 cm. Always stock for the size the fish will be, not the size it is.
  • It ignores behaviour. Territorial cichlids need floor space, fast swimmers need length, and shoaling fish need company.
  • It ignores your filter and your habits. A big filter and weekly water changes support more fish than a small filter and monthly ones.

Real tank capacity

A tank sold as 100 litres rarely holds 100 litres of water once gravel, rock, wood and the gap at the top are in. Knock off 15 to 20% and work from that.

Tank size (sold as)Real waterSmall community fish (3 to 5 cm adult)Good for
30 to 40 L25 to 32 LAbout 10 to 12 nano fishOne small shoal, shrimp, a betta on its own
60 LAbout 50 LAbout 18 to 22One shoal, a few bottom dwellers
100 to 120 L80 to 100 LAbout 30 to 40Two shoals, corydoras, a centrepiece
180 to 200 L150 to 170 LAbout 55 to 70Proper community, angelfish, bigger shoals
250 to 300 L210 to 250 LAbout 80 to 100Larger fish, big shoals, cichlid communities

These are ceilings for small, peaceful fish with a well-sized filter and weekly water changes, not targets. Stopping at three-quarters of the number gives you clearer water and healthier fish.

Example setups that work

60 litre community

  • 10 harlequin rasboras or 10 ember tetras
  • 6 pygmy or panda corydoras
  • 1 honey gourami
  • A few nerite snails

120 litre community

  • 12 neon or cardinal tetras
  • 8 bronze or peppered corydoras
  • 1 pair of dwarf gouramis or a group of 3 honey gouramis
  • 1 bristlenose pleco
  • Amano shrimp for algae

200 litre community

  • 3 to 4 angelfish (added young, together)
  • 15 rummy-nose tetras
  • 10 corydoras
  • 6 kuhli loaches
  • 1 bristlenose pleco

Check each species’ page for its own temperature and water needs before you buy, and see aquarium water parameters for what your tap water suits.

Six things that matter more than the number

  1. Adult size. Look it up before you buy, every time. Common traps: common plecos, clown loaches, iridescent sharks, red-tailed black sharks, oscars.
  2. Group size. Shoaling fish (tetras, rasboras, corydoras) need 6 or more, ideally 8 to 10. A lone neon is a stressed neon.
  3. Swimming level. Spread fish across the top, middle and bottom. Three bottom-dwelling species fighting for the same floor is overstocking even if the numbers look fine.
  4. Temperament. Some fish nip fins, some claim territory. A 200 L tank can still be “full” with one aggressive cichlid in it.
  5. Filtration. Aim for a filter that turns over 4 to 6 times the tank’s volume per hour. More filter gives you more margin, but it doesn’t make an overcrowded tank happy.
  6. Your maintenance. Be honest. If water changes happen fortnightly, stock lighter.

How to stock a new tank

  1. Cycle first. No fish go in until the tank is cycled. See the nitrogen cycle, explained.
  2. Start hardy and small. First fish: a group of hardy shoaling fish such as zebra danios, harlequins or platies.
  3. Add in batches. A few fish every two weeks, testing ammonia and nitrite in between. Any reading above zero means wait.
  4. Peaceful first, bold last. Add shy and peaceful species before more confident ones, so newcomers don’t arrive into claimed territory.
  5. Centrepiece fish last. Gouramis, angelfish or a pleco go in once the tank is settled.
  6. Quarantine new arrivals for two to four weeks if you can. It’s the best protection against whitespot and other hitchhikers.

Signs your tank is overstocked

  • Nitrate climbs past 40 ppm within a week of a water change
  • Ammonia or nitrite readings above zero in an established tank
  • Constant chasing, torn fins, fish hiding all day
  • Fish gasping at the surface, especially in the morning
  • Persistent cloudy water or algae that won’t go (see aquarium algae)
  • Repeated disease outbreaks

The fix is bigger and more frequent water changes now, then rehoming some fish or upgrading the tank. Most good local fish shops will take healthy fish back or swap them.

Your questions, answered

How many fish in a 60 litre tank? Around 18 to 22 small fish (3 to 5 cm adult), for example a shoal of 10, six corydoras and one centrepiece. Fewer if any are larger.

How many neon tetras in a 100 litre tank? A shoal of 10 to 15 neons alongside some bottom dwellers and a centrepiece fish is a comfortable mix.

Does a bigger filter mean more fish? A little. Filters handle waste, but they don’t add swimming room or stop squabbles, and nitrate still builds up.

Do snails and shrimp count? Barely. Small shrimp and snails add very little waste. A big apple snail or a dozen ramshorns breeding away does count, though.

Is a goldfish OK in a bowl? No. Fancy goldfish need about 75 litres for the first one and more for each extra. Common goldfish belong in a pond.

Next reads: The nitrogen cycle · Water parameters · Fish Health Clinic · Start here

Planning a stocking list? Post your tank size, filter and the fish you fancy in the comments and I’ll tell you if it works. — Graham

Get in touch I’d love to hear from you

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.